How to win at auction

How to win at auction (without doing anything stupid)!

The auction room is where good intentions meet reality.

You’ve done the work—research, inspections, maybe a few late-night spreadsheets—and now you’re sitting there thinking: “Right, let’s win this thing.”

Good. But winning at auction isn’t about bravado. It’s about preparation, discipline, and knowing when to stop.

‍

Know your numbers (properly, not emotionally)

The night before the auction, you should have two numbers locked in. Not “rough ideas”. Actual numbers.

1. Your market value
What would you realistically pay today based on recent comparable sales?

2. Your absolute walk-away price
And here’s the important bit—don’t make it tidy.

Not $1,500,000.

Something like $1,537,000.

Because auctions don’t respect round numbers, and neither should you.

If you can’t be that specific, you’re not ready yet.

‍

Understand your auction personality

Most buyers fall into one of three camps:

‍

1. The Fast Starter

Jumps in early, sets the tone, tries to take control.

Pros:

• Can shake out the competition early
• Puts pressure on other buyers

Cons:

• You might overcommit too soon
• You reveal your hand early

2. Mr or Mrs Wait-and-See

Classic New Zealand approach: arms folded, nodding, “just watching & waiting to be on the market.”

Pros:

• Lets you read the room
• Avoids early bidding wars

Cons:

• You don’t control anything
• Sometimes you watch the property sell without you
• The property can be sold off the floor without prior warning.. risky!

‍

3. The Sniper

Waits. Watches. Moves late.

Pros:

• Can catch others off guard
• Strong psychological advantage if timed well

Cons:

• One hesitation too many and it’s gone
• I’ve seen plenty of “perfect timing” buyers become “congratulations to the other bidder” buyers

‍

Get your finance right before you fall in love

A top-tier mortgage broker isn’t optional in this game.

They don’t just help you borrow money—they help you structure it properly so you can bid with confidence when it matters.

Two brokers I’ve personally seen do this well:

• Dylan Thomas – Sixtus
• Grant Stephens – HelloYello

Get that sorted well before auction day, even before you start looking, not during the search!

‍

Don’t be afraid to ask questions

If you’re unsure in the room, ask.

Auctioneers aren’t there to trick you—they’re there to run a process. Clarify bids, timing, or conditions if you need to. Confidence comes from understanding what’s actually happening, not guessing.

The real question (and this is the one that matters)

At some point, you’ll find yourself in a competitive auction for a home you genuinely like.

And this is where things get interesting.

Because it’s not about whether you can afford it.

It’s about whether you’re actually prepared to fight for it.

My wife and I went through this exact thing back in 2013 when we bought our first home in Ellerslie. I ended up going about 10% over my “top price.”

Not because I got carried away. Because I knew it was the right long-term home, and I wasn’t going to lose it over a number I’d made up a week earlier.

Final thought

Winning at auction isn’t about being the loudest bidder in the room.

It’s about being the one who already decided—before the auction started—what success looks like.

Everyone else is just reacting.

‍